In the landscape of modern media, passive strategies are becoming a relic of the past. As Netflix’s Nobody Wants This captured the zeitgeist with its second season, it introduced more than just a romantic subplot—it sparked a cultural debate. When the character Morgan (Justine Lupe) dismisses the viral "Let Them" theory—a philosophy of detached acceptance—in favor of her own "Make Them" approach, she articulated a shift that resonates far beyond the screen. For public relations professionals and brand strategists, this is not merely a piece of pop-culture dialogue; it is a tactical blueprint for navigating an increasingly noisy information ecosystem.
The "Make Them" theory posits that rather than waiting for respect, recognition, or opportunity to arrive, one must proactively engineer the circumstances to command them. In the high-stakes world of PR, where visibility, credibility, and influence are the primary currencies, this assertive stance is redefining how agencies and in-house teams operate.
Main Facts: The Philosophy of Proactive Influence
At its core, the "Make Them" mentality is the antithesis of the "wait-and-see" approach. In traditional communications, many firms have relied on reactive pitching—waiting for a company milestone, a product launch, or a quarterly report to engage the press. However, the current media climate, defined by fragmented audiences and a 24-hour news cycle, renders reactive PR increasingly ineffective.
The transition from "Let Them" to "Make Them" involves four critical pillars:
- Engineered Relevance: Proactively creating the news rather than waiting for it to materialize.
- Strategic Crisis Management: Shaping the narrative trajectory after negative coverage occurs.
- Relational Capital: Investing in deep, human-centric connections before the need for a favor arises.
- Goal-Oriented Visibility: Ensuring that every ounce of earned attention aligns with a measurable business objective.
Chronology: From Passive Pitching to Strategic Engineering
The evolution of PR strategy has moved in tandem with the democratization of media. Two decades ago, the gatekeepers were few, and the process was linear: a brand announced, and the press reported.
- The Early 2000s: The era of the "Press Release." Brands waited for formal events to reach out to journalists. The success rate was tied to the volume of outreach.
- The 2010s: The rise of digital content. Brands began to focus on content marketing, yet often remained siloed in their internal news cycles.
- The 2024-2026 Shift: The current era. Influencer culture, the saturation of TikTok, and the reliance on "wellness" and "lifestyle" integration have forced brands to insert themselves into cultural conversations where they have no inherent business being.
A recent case study involves a tart cherry juice brand. Rather than waiting for a scientific study or a massive distribution deal to pitch, the team identified the "wellness darty" (day party) trend among Gen Z. By positioning the product as a healthy, performance-enhancing alternative at these events, the brand secured organic coverage. This was not a traditional product launch; it was a manufactured moment of cultural relevance, bridging the gap between a CPG commodity and a viral lifestyle movement.
Supporting Data and The Economics of Attention
The transition to a "Make Them" strategy is supported by the changing nature of media consumption. According to recent industry benchmarks, the "click-through" value of a passive press release has plummeted by nearly 40% over the last five years. Conversely, stories that connect to broader cultural trends—such as the wellness shift or sustainability in fitness—see a 3x higher engagement rate.
Furthermore, the "Make Them" theory requires a move away from the "all press is good press" fallacy. Data indicates that negative sentiment, if not immediately addressed through active reframing, can suppress the efficacy of future positive announcements by up to 60%. When a brand experiences a controversy, the "Make Them" approach mandates that the firm provides a more complete narrative immediately. This does not mean spinning the truth; it means providing the context that the audience needs to form a balanced opinion, effectively "making" the reader see the bigger picture.
Official Perspectives and Expert Insight
For communications leaders, the philosophy is a return to the roots of the industry: human connection. Remi Yuter, Senior Communications Specialist at Hot Paper Lantern, notes that while the "Make Them" mindset is assertive, it must be guided by high-level strategy.

"The best media opportunities aren’t always the ones that find you," Yuter explains. "Often they’re the ones you make happen." However, Yuter warns against the mistake of "noise." "Being assertive without a strategy is just making noise. The goal isn’t attention for attention’s sake. It’s earning the kind of attention that builds awareness, strengthens reputation and creates momentum."
This perspective is echoed by veteran journalists, who note that they are increasingly fatigued by "spray and pray" pitching. The professionals who successfully "make them" listen are those who demonstrate a profound understanding of the reporter’s beat. They are the ones who follow up on personal details—a child’s birth, a home repair, a specific interest—not to manipulate, but to build a foundation of mutual professional respect.
Implications for the Future of PR
What does the "Make Them" era mean for the future of the industry?
1. The Death of the Generic Pitch
The era of the bulk-email pitch is ending. To "make" a journalist pay attention, the pitch must be so highly tailored that it feels like a personalized invitation to a conversation rather than a request for coverage.
2. Crisis as an Opportunity to Pivot
The "Make Them" approach changes the crisis response from a defensive crouch to an offensive pivot. When negative press hits, the firm that controls the context—by proactively identifying and sharing the missing pieces of the story—is the one that emerges with its reputation intact.
3. The Rise of the "Cultural Connector"
PR pros are becoming less like "media relations managers" and more like "cultural connectors." The job description now includes identifying emerging trends—like the wellness darty movement—and finding the "hooks" that make a brand relevant within those spaces.
4. Intentionality as a Competitive Advantage
Finally, the most significant implication is the necessity of strategy. In a world where anyone can "make noise" on social media, the PR professional who succeeds is the one who understands exactly what they are working toward. Are we building brand awareness? Driving lead generation? Defending against a crisis? Each objective requires a different type of "Make Them" strategy.
Conclusion: Crafting the Narrative
As Morgan’s character in Nobody Wants This suggests, there is a fundamental power in deciding not to wait for the world to notice you. In public relations, this is a call to arms. It is a reminder that while we cannot always control the headlines, we can exert a significant amount of influence over the narrative arc of our brands.
The "Make Them" theory is not about aggression; it is about intentionality. It is about recognizing that your brand’s story is a living, breathing entity that requires active stewardship. By creating opportunities, responding with transparency and context, nurturing genuine relationships, and focusing on strategic goals, PR professionals can move from the sidelines to the center of the conversation. In the end, the most enduring media coverage isn’t the kind that happens by accident—it’s the kind that is built, piece by piece, through the courage to make it happen.
