Main Facts
Creators rule the modern marketing landscape. Throughout the year, digital-first personalities command substantial budgets, dictate platform trends, and frequently take center stage in global campaigns. Yet, as the holiday season rolls around, a peculiar phenomenon occurs: they largely vanish from the most visible, highly budgeted real estate in advertising—the Christmas commercial.
The first major batch of festive campaigns for the holiday season—featuring entries from legacy and modern brands alike, including John Lewis, SharkNinja, Ulta Beauty, and Burberry—bypasses the industry’s favorite digital obsession entirely. Instead of leaning on TikTok stars or YouTube mainstays, marketers continue to rely on traditional Hollywood celebrities, television actors, and sports stars to carry the weight of the year-end shopping rush.
Sephora’s holiday campaign casts actor Seth Rogen as a man hopelessly out of his depth, rescued just in time by a brand Beauty Advisor. Kay Jewelers taps Saturday Night Live star Colin Jost to navigate the frantic, time-honored trope of hunting for the perfect present. Sports Direct pushes the cliché further with Nike athletes quietly guiding a bewildered uncle down store aisles. Meanwhile, Gucci enlists Mariah Carey—the seasonal equivalent of an honored relative passed from house to house every December—to front its holiday lineup.
This persistent divide highlights a deep-seated tension in contemporary marketing: while performance budgets and everyday social strategies have embraced the creator economy, the high-stakes world of Christmas advertising remains tethered to older, heavily guarded rules.
Chronology and Industry Shift
For decades, the anatomy of a Christmas ad has followed a rigid formula: a cinematic film, a broad multi-generational audience, massive budgets requiring senior-most sign-offs, and a universally recognized famous face.
- The Traditional Playbook (Pre-2020s): Holiday spots were designed to act as mass-market unifiers. Brands competed on emotional storytelling, often spending months in production to deliver a singular, high-gloss television commercial meant to capture the entire family sitting around the living room TV.
- The Rise of the Creator Economy (2020–2024): Brands rapidly shifted digital ad dollars toward creators, recognizing their authentic connections with niche communities. However, these partnerships were largely relegated to lower-funnel digital activations, unboxings, and platform-specific social campaigns rather than hero-level brand spots.
- The Blurring Lines (Late 2024–Present): Signs of a convergence are beginning to show. Forward-thinking brands are starting to experiment with hybrid models, placing traditional celebrities and digital creators side-by-side. Campaigns from SharkNinja, Marc Jacobs, and Anthropologie indicate that the ironclad barrier keeping creators out of premier seasonal slots is beginning to crack.
Supporting Data and Campaign Case Studies
The reluctance to abandon traditional talent is driven by the sheer financial and reputational stakes of the holiday quarter. Christmas ads are heavily scrutinized, and straying from the formula can invite severe public backlash.
Consider John Lewis’s high-profile holiday spot. Within a day of its release, the commercial drew intense criticism from media figures like Piers Morgan—who labeled it "possibly the worst advert I’ve ever seen"—while consumer groups debated the behavior of the characters. While the ad’s star, Dame Kristin Scott Thomas, emerged unscathed, the incident underscores the vulnerability CMOs face when trying to innovate during peak shopping seasons.
Conversely, risk can yield high conversation volumes, even if reception is mixed. Tesco’s Christmas ad starring comedian Roisin Conaty and actor Anna Maxwell Martin became the most talked-about commercial in the U.K., according to Sprout Social data:
- Volume: Over 3,263 mentions and posts across social platforms.
- Engagement: More than 36,000 total interactions, including likes, comments, and shares.
- Sentiment: Divided, with only 51% of conversations registering as positive due to viewer debates over the ad’s realistic portrayal of retail operations. Nevertheless, the campaign achieved what most festive ads fail to do: it forced the country to talk.
Other brands are attempting to bridge the gap between niche digital followings and mass-market recognition.
- SharkNinja: Utilized a teaser strategy featuring a fluid mix of traditional stars and cultural heavyweights—including Kevin Hart, David Beckham, Aryna Siarhiejeŭna, and Tom Brady—who dropped short clips on social media days before the main commercial aired.
- Marc Jacobs: Crafted a holiday party narrative starring comedian Megan Stalter alongside a diverse ensemble that included New York Knicks center Andre Drummond, social media personality Ashtin Earle, model Kai Schreiber, and designer Miyako Bellizzi, granting digital creators the same high-tier billing as traditional talent.
- Anthropologie: Handed its entire holiday campaign to comedian and digital creator Pooja Tripathi (creator of the web series Brooklyn Coffee Shop), who wrote and showrun a micro-comedy series. The rollout functioned like a traditional movie premiere, supported by an army of 50 additional creators spreading the narrative across Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Pinterest, and Reddit.
Official Responses and Expert Perspectives
Industry leaders point out that the division between creators and celebrities comes down to scale, safety, and cultural ubiquity.
"Part of the reason brands use celebrities in ads is because they’re borrowing fame," explains Lynne Deason, head of creative excellence at Kantar. "Christmas is this mass-market moment where brands are trying to reach everyone, and so often brands are looking for a celebrity that everyone will recognize rather than maybe a particular audience."
Deason notes that while creators are building massive personal brands, they often remain tied to specific interests or demographics.
"That’s perhaps harder with creators because people tend to tap into them for particular interests. Obviously, there are some who are becoming very famous in their own right with mass audiences, but there are fewer of those. And Christmas is such a competitive time."
From the brand executive’s chair, the pressure to conform is intense, yet playing it safe can occasionally backfire in a crowded market.
"A CMO is always looking for ideas they couldn’t get inside the company," says Linda Boff, former CMO of GE and CEO of independent marketing services group Said Differently. "Fresh, bold ideas that zag when everyone else zigs. Having been on that side of the table, I know the pressure to deliver results, especially during the holidays. But when everyone follows the same formula, playing it safe can actually be the bigger risk."
Recognizing this evolution, legacy organizations are restructuring their operations to secure top-tier talent. The LEGO Group recently poached Kelsey Gray Sherman from agency WME to fill a newly created role as head of celebrity talent and brand-first partnerships.
When asked about the future integration of digital talent within major toy and entertainment collaborations, Gray Sherman emphasized that the distinction is rapidly dissolving:
"That absolutely includes creators. The distinction between ‘traditional celebrity’ and creator is increasingly less meaningful to audiences, so the brand’s approach to building and executing relationships with all manner of talent reflects that."
Gray Sherman added that modern brand partnerships no longer require product placement as an initial point of entry:
"Embracing ‘brand-first partnerships’ is not about moving away from product innovation—it is about recognizing the expanding ways two partners can create mutual value for each other and stand-out experiences for fans."
Implications for the Future of Marketing
The absence of creators from peak holiday ad slots should not be misread as a permanent rejection of the creator economy. Rather, it marks a transitional phase. As top-tier creators continue to pull in audiences that rival traditional television networks, and as Hollywood actors increasingly adopt creator-like behaviors—filming self-contained content and speaking directly to fans via personal social feeds—the boundary between the two worlds is dissolving.
The coming years will likely see a structural evolution in holiday campaigns:
- Blended Rosters: Brands will routinely pair household-name celebrities with digital-native creators to capture both mass recognition and hyper-engaged niche segments.
- Entertainment-First Frameworks: Advertisers will move away from rigid, one-off television spots toward serialized, episodic holiday content conceptualized and executed by digital creators from script to screen.
- In-House Talent Infrastructure: As demonstrated by LEGO’s strategic hires, brands will institutionalize talent management to maintain consistency across traditional entertainment deals, gaming collaborations, and creator partnerships year-round.
For now, the "tinsel ceiling" remains largely intact for mainstream Christmas commercials, guarded by CMOs seeking the reliable safety blanket of traditional fame. But as audiences age out of traditional media consumption, the traditional holiday ad formula faces inevitable disruption. The question facing marketing executives is no longer if creators will take over the holiday ad break, but which brand will be brave enough to let them lead first.
